| Platinum | Coldwater Thrift and Collectables |
| Gold | Once Upon a Child |
| Silver | Alliston's Attic |
| Bronze | Orillia Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | Cloud Nine Emporium |
| Top Pick | Habitat For Humanity Restore |
| Top Pick | Kid's Closet |
| Top Pick | Nine Lives Thrift Store & Boutique |
| Top Pick | re-Source THRIFT SHOP |
| Top Pick | Treasure Tails |