| Platinum | Greekery Bakeshop |
| Gold | A Piece of Comfort Bakery & Co |
| Silver | Karas Cookies |
| Silver | Little Laura's Big Sweets |
| Bronze | Drizzled by Adrienne |
| Top Pick | Cookie Diva |
| Top Pick | The Baker's Bench |
| Top Pick | The Sugar Bar |
| Top Pick | Urban Grind Coffee Co |
| Top Pick | Whisk It Good |