| Platinum | Coldwater Thrift and Collectables |
| Gold | The Christmas Villager |
| Silver | Event Horizon Hobbies |
| Bronze | Marlynn's Hamster |
| Top Pick | Cards and Coasters |
| Top Pick | From Jess With Joy |
| Top Pick | Puzzles and Pastimes Hobby Shop |
| Top Pick | Taiden's Treehouse |
| Top Pick | The Candy Shoppe |
| Top Pick | The Spotted Rabbit |