| Platinum | Catch 22 Fresh Market Grill |
| Gold | The Arch Steakhouse |
| Silver | Town and Country |
| Bronze | Lot 88 Orillia |
| Top Pick | Barcelos Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Chucks Roadhouse Wasaga Beach |
| Top Pick | Gušt |
| Top Pick | Rock Dell Steak House & Tavern |
| Top Pick | Table For 2 |
| Top Pick | The Keg |