| Platinum | Catch 22 Fresh Market Grill |
| Gold | Fish & Sips |
| Silver | Picnic Tapas and Wine |
| Bronze | Lakeside Seafood & Grill |
| Top Pick | Cocina Mexicana |
| Top Pick | Fin City Fish & Chips |
| Top Pick | Harbor Seafood Coldwater On |
| Top Pick | Harbour Street Fish Bar |
| Top Pick | The Iron Skillet |