| Platinum | Nonna's Cucina |
| Gold | Che Roba |
| Silver | Zio's Italian Comfort Food |
| Bronze | Poppi's Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | 147 |
| Top Pick | Casa Mia Barrie |
| Top Pick | Firehall Pizza Co. |
| Top Pick | Fuda Italian Bakery |
| Top Pick | Rustica Pizza Vino |
| Top Pick | The Italian Eatery |